Book Review: The Center Cannot Hold By Elyn R. Saks (Last blog "draft" guys)

As a fellow struggling with schizophrenia himself, I found Elyn Saks memoir to be very inspirational. Although everyone’s schizophrenia is different, I was able to get a lot out of the book. Her details of what it’s like to be in psychosis are impressive. As was her ability to bounce back everytime an episode would occur in her life.

She seems to have been able to bury herself in work throughout most of her life, and it is with this work ethic of hers, that it was almost impossible for her to fail. It’s impressive that she was able to cope with her mental illness and also excel with her coursework at Vanderbuilt undergrad, then Oxford graduate school, and then again at Yale law school.

And it was courageous of her to come out with this “tell all” being that she has a good job teaching nowadays, at a law school in Los Angeles. With schizophrenia and the stigma associated with it, it is easy, almost impossible not to have a “spotty history” regarding who you have let in, and who you have kept it secret from, with several shades of gray in between.

One dissenter friend of hers for example, warned that she should publish under a pseudonym because “Did she really want to be known as the [schizophrenic with a job]?” But her rationale was the same as mine which I found supportive. First she thought, “Is that all I am?”, and in addition she felt that a big part of her motivation for writing the memoir was to help lessen the burden of stigma that mental illness comes with. It would have been much less effective if she had written her life story under a fake name.

Fortunately for me I do not share Elyn Sak’s pattern of trying to go it alone when it comes to family, and also medication. Personally I went off medication once for a year and everything was going well until suddenly the wheels fell off the bus, and I spent a good month not knowing what was real. I thought for example that the mafia wanted me dead and that they were planning something sadistic for me.

After living through that nightmare of an experience I will never go without my prescribed medication again. But it took Ms. Saks several trial and error periods throughout her 20s and 30s before she learned this lesson as well. She felt that if she used meds(drugs) it meant she was weak, or defective. It took a lot of time and talk therapy before the lesson was finally ingrained in her.

I learned in the memoir that reading is important because Elyn Saks is an avid reader, and it is my assumption that this probably helped boost brain power, and made her more prepared to tackle her life’s challenges. It is probably a big part of the reason for why she was able to make the amount of friends she did, friendships that spanned decades of time and thousands of miles of distance. I respect people who take in books, and/or have a passion for reading. Mostly because I struggle with it. But I think it made her more interesting, and gave her more to talk about. One drawback to the book if anything is that Ms. Saks does not stuggle with the so called negative symptoms of the disorder(traits which are not present but should be). She doesn’t struggle with avolition as I do.

Still I found her story inspiring and was really glad at the end to learn that she found a man who loves her and that they are together today. Her story really hammers home what is important, and that is, work you find meaningful, and also relationships and connections with family and friends.

I’m eager to read more about the disorder that affects me, as well as eager to teach what I learn as well.

3 Likes

Nice review. Maybe you could share more information about the book for those who can’t afford to buy it

1 Like

Thank you @Om_Sadasiva, unfortunately this review was written by me in 2012. The saving grace is that I wrote it immediately after reading the book. I suppose the biggest takeaway is for us to try to exercise our minds, to boost brain power, like she did.

The only tidbit I recall that I didn’t include in the review is that she was a smoker for approx. 20 years before she was able to quit. But she did develop cancer, and had to have a hysterectomy and therefore couldn’t have children of her own. But she does find love toward the end of the book.

2 Likes

She is inspiration for all of us. Thank you

1 Like

Don’t give up hope. Negative symptoms can get better, too.

1 Like

Yes I believe I’ve witnessed that already… I wrote this awhile back when I was showering very infrequently. That cleared up for years until I recently fell back into nicotine, which reduces motivation for brushing teeth, and taking showers for me. I’ve let people down by going back, and if I can’t quit with self discipline, Wellbutrin may help. Thank you @anon9798425… hope is a big theme that I think on.

1 Like

@anon64158233

That was a well-written review.

In her TED talk, Dr. Saks credits finding love as possibly the most significant factor in her recovery, with medication compliance and staying out of the psychiatric hospital a close second.Among other accolades, Dr. Saks has a Ph.D. in psychoanalysis, and ascribes to Freud’s belief that the purpose of life is found in love and work.

Dr. Saks is inspirational.

2 Likes

Love it. Those two things are currently lacking in my life yet I’m stable. That means I have a lot of potential to be happier. Achieving one or both would really just be a bonus the way my expectations are set.

1 Like

Wow. Nice review!

I really want to read her book. I just finished John Nash’s biography, which I recommend for you to read.

Regarding negative symptoms, they really do disable us. If I didn’t have negative symptoms, I would be a completely different person and I cannot fathom what it would be like. I had really bad positives too, but I felt the negatives were more disabling.

It seems for me, the negatives are lessening over time. I estimate at least a 20% decrease with the right supplements and medicines.

She is an inspiration to us all!

2 Likes

I really enjoyed reading her book.
She is inspirational but it’s important to note that she didn’t suffer from negative symptoms.

2 Likes

Haha thanks! I attempted John Nash’s book once but didn’t get very far. It went too far into mathematics I thought. If you can get through that, you’ll definitely be able to enjoy The Center Cannot Hold.

What supplements are working for you? I don’t know much about them… I tried sarcosine briefly but I had trouble drawing conclusions. I may try that again.

1 Like

Ya some of the math was confusing. If I didn’t understand, I skipped through it. I was still able to get through and understand the book.

I’m currently on sarcosine, ashwagandha, and l theanine.

1 Like

I should attempt to revisit that book. I like the movie and also the soundtrack too.

That’s cool that you were able to skip some parts and not give up… I get to be like a perfectionist and feel annoyed if I cant read a book cover to cover.

Also I love buying books but usually only start them…

1 Like

Ya, I have a habit of buying too many books. If you really want to know the math in the book, you could try looking it up. I just skimmed some of it. I was a math major but dropped out. Some of it was technical. It wasn’t easy to read.

1 Like

Ok. But I suppose there are some big payoffs to reading it. I feel like I should since I’ve seen the movie a lot. I think John Nash is actually the most famous person with sz if I’m not mistaken. Second place is Einstein’s son. Although this is all Internet knowledge. Nonetheless there aren’t many famous people with it bc it strikes young.

Also I once skimmed a memoir by Kurt Vonnegut’s son. He thought he had schizophrenia but he claims he cured it with vitamins… so there weren’t many takeaways for me because I don’t believe that’s possible.

An article in the newspaper came out around the time I had just got diagnosed and had started seeing a psychologist. He showed me the article and tried to give me hope that I could recover too.

1 Like

This is a 7-minute YouTube video featuring the late John Nash, Jr. and his son Johnny, who also has schizophrenia:

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 95 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.