[quote=“shutterbug, post:13, topic:24277”]All I’m asking is that those who are providing guidance about alternate therapies lay their cards on the table so that those who are looking at following them have an idea of where the information is coming from.
Worth pointing out that the AA concept of a Higher Power may have nothing to do with mysticism or actual spiritual beings and could just be a useful psychological trick. I make no claims in this department. It works for me, but others may find their mileage varies.
[/quote]
i presume this thread was directed at me, due to recently joining here & the theme of some of my posts (many of which have been deleted).
i’m honest & have laid my cards on the table. i haven’t offered guidance - simply opened up discussion on a broader view of what people experience.
i gave a brief overview here - Complimentary Healing
Carl Jung was critical in the formation of AA, & it’s spiritual basis (without Jung AA wouldn’t exist) - as was the temperance movement & all of it’s religious overtones. There is a lot within 12 step that has it’s basis in religious & spiritual systems - & any deeper look into it all shows that. Don’t want to get into a long discussion on my opinion on it all - But the core message was/is that alcoholism at core is a spiritual dilemma with a spiritual solution, & the entire program centers around God & spiritual principles/transformation, universal to many areas of spirituality.
My own views on mental health have come from my own personal experience, & a lot of reading/research into this area - hundreds of books, thousands of hours of research, & many thousands of hours of conversations. i think there is a spiritual/transpersonal component to psychosis - that is all, & i think there should be far more of an awareness around it all, & capacity for people to explore that element of their experiences, if they so choose to. That there ought to be far more comprehensive, humane & compassionate approaches to it all.
i think the current dominant biomedical psychiatric/scientific reductionist view on schizophrenia is wrong & i think it can be very well argued as to why it’s wrong. i think that people should be freely allowed to express whatever their view is on these matters without censorship or attack.
No mater - i won’t change the system & the system isn’t going to change - am still entitled to an opinion - Despite the continuing closing down of free speech in our societies & the almost exclusive materialist paradigm that everyone it seems must conform & acquiesce to.