I saw it tonight. Unsettling movie and not for everyone for sure. People who claimed it to be a a “mockery” of mental illness (so far, only in that Independent article) do it in relation to its comic book context. But if you diminish the context it is unbelievably realistic - thus why hard to swallow - story about a man with mental illness put into the society that wasn’t able to offer him anything but abuse and neglect. It has a very strong social message, specially in relation to the treatment of disabled people or people not fitting into the standards of normality whatsoever.
Joackin Phoenix gave an outstanding performance and deserves all the praises.
It might be triggering to watch for some…though i found a comfort through some layers of identification with his struggles.
Just got back from seeing it, and I have to say it was intense. The acting was amazing, and while I dont like how many times they said he was mentally ill, it wasn’t as bad as i thought it would be. The climax when he tells his last joke was the one that annoyed me. I won’t spoil it here.
It was hard not to empathize with him up until a point. After he found out about his past, as traumatic as it was, it still didn’t justify what followed.
I think it was over hyped for being a praise the villain movie. If anything bad does happen, it’s because the media influenced it by drawing more attention to it for the wrong reasons than it deserved. I didnt really see the movie as justifying what he did, I think it was more of a social statement.
Just my two cents.
Great movie, not as dangerous as I thought it would be. Very very dark and depressing. When you think it couldnt get any worse, it does.