Adult coloring books - what`s up with that?

I could certainly recall numerous times when i stole my kids homework. :slight_smile:

"…Chances are you’ve already heard it’s the year of the adult coloring book. Publications have touted the books’ ability to help adults “de-stress and self-express”. Coloring has been said to be able to help you achieve mindfulness, banish anxiety, and even deal with trauma. Some of the books explicitly label themselves as “art therapy.”

Is this trend as great as it’s cracked up to be? We asked some professionals.

Cathy Malchiodi, an art therapist, wrote critically about adult coloring. “Some people are adamant that coloring books are a path to mindfulness, meditation and some kind of psychological nirvana,” Malchiodi said over the phone. “I find that many of the loudest proponents are actually those that create the coloring books.”

Malchiodi admitted to finding the trend disappointing. “This year, there have been several really good studies about why people should engage in creative activity, which doesn’t involve coloring in someone else’s designs,” she said, citing a study that was released by the Mayo Clinic this spring.“It involves actually pursuing some form of art-making. It can be very helpful to people’s mental health and physical health."

The gist of the criticism? If you want to color, knock yourself out, but don’t call it meditation or therapy.

Drena Fagen, an art therapist and an adjunct instructor at New York University’s Steinhardt School, has a rosier view of the books, and said she has actually used them in therapy sessions. Still, she makes a distinction between the books and therapy: “I don’t consider the coloring books as art therapy; I consider the coloring books therapeutic, which is not the same thing.”

Fagen said that the activity can be mindful or mindless, depending on how one approaches it. “Any creative endeavor that can in some way help somebody discover something about themselves or find a space that makes them feel safe and comfortable or allows them an opportunity to be with their own thoughts, I don’t see how we can criticize that. It seems like it’s only bringing good things to the world.”

Bennett echoed Fagen, saying that although there isn’t “the research support for coloring specifically” as a treatment, it can be part of a larger plan for coping with uncomfortable feelings. "

( Guardian)

2 Likes

I love coloring. I have a Mandalay book and enjoy stamping and coloring.

Adult coloring books were recommended to me as an activity to keep busy and calm when I quit smoking. I used colored pencils and kept pleasantly occupied that way for hours and hours each day for the first two days I quit. After I was over the nicotine withdrawal I lost interest in them.

3 Likes

I love my adult coloring book. It is very relaxing.

I tried coloring. I thought I’d like it. I found it boring.

I have two. Have not even looked in them. I hate anhedonia. I want to feel the happiness and joy of doing something fun and relaxing.

I loved my coloring books whenI was a kid. I used to do coloring when my kids were small. That was before I got ill.

If I had free time, (yeah, right), I’d be out taking pictures. Or working on the next episode of a podcast. Currently loading playlists onto backup devices (old iPods) and loading speakers into my van for an Oktoberfest dance I’m DJing this evening. 4H starts tomorrow so I’m back again as a leader. Hope I get the shopping and housework done in time before I go.

Wish I had time to colour something!

Pixel.

I used to hangout with a fellow guy with scz who loved coloring books. At first I thought it was bizarre and cooky, then I heard about people doing it all the time.

I myself would probably go crazier, I like more stimulating and challenging things.

But if it works, and it’s not unhealthy, do it!

3 Likes

I thought that Octoberfest is a Germany thing.: )

It’s a beer thing. Canadians can find pretty much any excuse to drink beer. Like, Wednesday.

Pixel.

1 Like

I saw an adult colouring book on offer at Amazon the other day. I was really temped but was worried people would think its stupid at my age lol

Just finished my Benedict Cumberbatch colouring book

Therapeutic
Not like therapy
Art therapy is also different from therapeutic art
Art therapy is a very deep therapy often focusing on family and I’ve done it once a week in rehab
I’ve done yoga meditation and mandala drawing retreats with Jo Pelly
artist and exceptional yoga teacher and speaker
These retreats were mostly silent but there was one where everyone was naughty and we all spoke
Deeply meaningful art and processes took place for everyone at the end of the week was a show and tell for everyone which was always mindblowing

2 Likes

I have a few of those. :sunglasses:

Ish - just do it!
It’s great and relaxing

1 Like

Wanna see wanna see!!!pliiiiz :smiley:

I just bought one with colouring pencils :smile: just waiting …

3 Likes

I need a new one
I think she has (Mel - colour me good - series of books)
Another one with just loads of different male actors
Need to buy it now!!

Got this one https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1574219715/ref=cm_sw_r_awd_XLcewbS2TVNPQ

2 Likes

Wow, gorgeous!!!

1 Like

My pdoc suggested it. To me years ago. It helps me practice focusing on one thing at a time especially when the voices are high.

1 Like