Primary, Enduring Negative Symptoms: An Update on Research

Abstract

We previously proposed that people with schizophrenia who have primary, enduring negative symptoms have a disease—deficit schizophrenia (DS)—that is separate from that affecting people with schizophrenia without these features. Additional evidence consistent with the separate disease hypothesis has accumulated in recent years. White matter changes may be widespread in deficit compared to nondeficit patients and may relate to problems in early brain migration. These 2 patient groups also appear to differ on metabolic measures prior to antipsychotic treatment. Studies of reward and defeatist beliefs provide the basis for future treatment trials. The 2 factors or groups within negative symptoms broadly defined (both primary and secondary) have also been found in DS, and recent evidence suggests these 2 symptom groups have different correlates and reflect the existence of 2 groups with in DS. Negative symptoms are found in disorders other than schizophrenia, and excess summer birth, a deficit risk factor, has been found in a non-patient group with deficit-like features. It may be useful in future research to determine whether findings in DS extend to patients with other neuropsychiatric disorders who also have negative symptoms.

I simply don’t agree with the “defeatist beliefs” part. It’s a red herring.
It’s easy to assume that deficit schizophrenics are afraid of change, are afraid to leave the comfort zone, to take risks etc. But it’s not true. There is nothing wrong with our psychology. We just can’t do things anymore that were once easy and attainable.
They must look deeper into the genetics of negative symptoms.
White matter abnormalities - indeed it is a good lead. However they might have existed prior to illness onset, which means they are only a byproduct and not the primary cause, since if that’s the case, it means we were able to function even in the presence of said abnormalities, albeit for a limited time before the illness kicked in.

2 Likes