For me i hear both internal and external voices. As to say whether they are both from schizophrenia, the answer for me is yes they both are. ive talked with god and the devil both internally only, and had long conversations with them, when i was out of it.
The external voices, are more rare for me, are very short and to the point. so yes those things can be considered schizophrenic if the person is not thinking it themselves and it is an intrusion on their normal thought process. But thats how i see it. Seeing as how you heard them at night can also be a sign that its schizophrenic as thats how my voices show up when i am medicated, if im not medicated i talk to them throughout the day. Since i am medicated, they show up more at night because that is when they are the strongest.
1 Like