I’m that kind of person who just really likes everything to be neat, and a few hours ago, I dismissed all of the topics that were in my New and Unread categories and now on the front page of the site, it only shows the blue “new” next to topics that were recently posted. As for the updates on the topics that were already here, I don’t see any blue circles next to the ones I’ve posted on nor the blue “new” next to the name.
I don’t know if you can get it back? Since you told the board to consider all threads as read, you’ll only get “new” on threads posted since then. You should still get the blue number circle for threads that have updated since you dismissed them that you’ve posted in, though?