There seems to be an easy simple answer to this.
There could be plant life, but for humans and animals to live, something has to die.
We have to eat.
I searched online for an answer to this and found long complicated answers that don’t make much sense to me. https://www.quora.com/Without-death-can-there-be-life
In my opinion, there can be no human or animal life without death.
It’s really not that complicated is it ?
The topic- " There’s a bit of the death lover in every man" @chordy made me think of this.
Death is an illusion. The death lover that I am learning to be is not “morbidity”.
“That which is below is like that which is above & that which is
above is like that which is below to do the miracles of one only thing”
“Its force is above all force. For it vanquishes every subtle thing & penetrates every solid thing.” - The “mysterious” Emerald Tablet as translated by Newton.
"Vegetarians are just as mistaken as their opponents. If you did not want to contribute to the killing of living beings, you could only drink milk, for whoever eats fruit or eggs still kills embryos. Milk is perhaps for that reason the healthiest food, because it is the most ethical. " - Otto Weininger’s Aphoristic Writings
The question posed…is the same as asking can there be light without dark…of course…since death and darkness are just the lack of life and light…with no death we would just be immortal…as without darkness it would be bright and shadowless…
A shadow is not created…it is the absence of light…your body is coming between our light source and whatever the shadows casting on…im not saying its probable to have a place with infinite light points of equal strength…thus rendering shadow gone…but you could have light without shadow…no one talks about the speed of dark…because dark isnt its own entity its the lack of light…
This is something I lay at the feet of God. Why oh why did he create such a scheme? In the state of nature the eating of carnivores is pretty grisly. The animals are alive much of the time they’re being eaten by lions, hyenas, or wolves.