Is A Size 12 A 'Plus' Size?

Many women, and to a lesser degree men, struggle with body image due to society’s definition of beauty. Disorders such as anorexia and bulimia are the result of this definition, and to a broader degree creates an environment conducive to body shaming.

I believe the fashion industry bears most of the responsibility by creating an unrealistic perception of beauty. The average woman in the U.S. is a size 16, yet ‘plus’ sizes begin at size 12. Consequently, many women feel ‘fat’ and unattractive, which results in low self-esteem.

Do you believe a size 12 is a ‘plus’ size?

3 Likes

I had to google it. It doesn’t look that big to me. :sweat:

4 Likes

I am not familiar with specific sizes but I do believe that Hollywood and the fashion industry paint an unrealistic picture of what is beautiful and acceptable as far as body types go. I hate the fact that eating disorders are so rampant, especially among the youth, due to these images that come at us daily through the media. Obesity is a problem in America, to be sure, but not everyone is fat who thinks they’re fat.

4 Likes

My wife wears sizes 1 or 3. I don’t know how big a 12 is. I am a guy and used to waist and inseam. I wear a 34 x 34 and extra large shirts.

2 Likes

I don’t think it is, actually

plus sized clothes start at about 16

but it’s also sad that it goes up to 4X

2 Likes

I know you mean well, by this thread,

but my daughter is a size 0-1

and she’s not starving herself

it’s hard to find enough foods today that are high calorie

when she’s home I make her homemade rich meals

1 Like

Plus a size 12 is different for every height and shape of a person. Someone who is short, say 5’1’’ looks much different in a size 12 short than I do in a 12 tall. When I was a size 12 I was also a 34x33 at 5’11" tall. I look much bigger than most people at my height but seems skinner than a short person of the same size.

1 Like

I’m concerned that the medical profession encourages people to be at an unhealthy weight. BMI (problematic anyway) standards were shifted in the 90s so that what used to be considered “normal” became “overweight.”

But major studies have shown that people who fall into the high “normal” and “overweight” categories live the longest, while people who are “normal” and on the low end of “obese” have comparable longevity.

I understand the interest the medical profession has in fighting morbid obesity, but it seems like they’ve gone too far in the other direction, to where they’re actively encouraging less healthy lifestyles and stigmatizing more healthy ones.

6 Likes

Rhubot, don’t say that

I know my daughter needs weight to live longer

I’ve been trying all my life

2 Likes

That’s what makes BMI so problematic - it doesn’t take individual people into account. As long as your daughter is eating well, getting exercise, and taking whatever precautions are prudent in avoiding infections, she’s doing exactly what she should be doing. It would be so unwise for her to sit around eating to excess just to get her weight up.

3 Likes

Yeah. I don’t know how many Scandi shakes, bars, McDonald’s, scandi powder, every doctor

says she’s on 25th percentile for height and weight

enzymes are excreted from the pancreas to make us digest food

she’s getting about 50 to 60 percent due to CF

all these young people are thin

plus the work of just breathing

100 pounds of air in each room

3 Likes

it’s a real catch, cuz yeah she has to do cardio

but I think she’d be better off lifting weights

1 Like

Come on Beth, we’re going down to Hardee’s for a monster thick burger…1300 calories

Yuck, mom.

3 Likes

I can’t really tell what a 12 is because I only am familiar with mens sizes and not the voodoo that they do to make women’s size so small. I know that it doesn’t mean 12 inches circumference. However I have seen some plus sized models who are attractive. Some that aren’t.

1 Like

I would say that size 12 ( european 44-46) is on the verge of overweight… Of course depends on the height and body type…
I watched a fitness coach on TV saying that "everything above 220 pounds is not healthy ". I could agree with that.

1 Like

What’s the smallest you’ve been Sarad, cuz you’re small.

I think I’ve gone as low as a size 6. Never below that.
But I’ve been on meds all these years, long, long time.

1 Like

I can tell from the pictures that you are very skinny too. Genetics play a big part…my mother is small so I’m a shorty too.

1 Like

I never stay one weight though

sometimes I’m bigger

idk, I’ve always done manual labor too

and ran races

I could eat whatever I wanted

2 Likes

if I’m fat, then I’m fat. relating weight to shame is another story.

so I don’t care if size 12 is a ‘plus’ size.

but I’m a dude, so yeah…

2 Likes

Don’t think it is, wish I were a size 12…

1 Like